In the wake of the Super Bowl, it’s only natural that an ad agency sound off on the commercials. Give their two cents on what worked and what didn’t. But as I tell people all too often, the more time we spend criticizing, the less room we make for creating. So this year’s Super Bowl blog post is more of an open forum. A
“leave you with something to think about” type deal.
In the last five years we’ve seen a trend emerge in Super Bowl advertising: that of the consumer-created TV spot. Between Doritos and Pepsi Max, PepsiCo had six consumer-created ads in the Super Bowl this year. SIX! That’s a whole lotta advertising dollars not going to the ad industry.
Now, as someone who makes a living off of being an ad creative, I must admit, when this trend first started, I was not happy about it. I won’t lie, I was mildly threatened and even a little offended that some Joe Shmoe thought he could do my job better than me. But as I’ve thought about it more and seen it evolve, I’ve discovered two things:
1. The premise of the consumer-created ad is quite smart really. In fact, the concept was actually created by an advertising agency. If you think about it, it’s nothing more than using a focus group to create the commercial, baiting them with money (albeit small) and 15 minutes of fame. Of course these people will hit the spot when it comes to speaking to the target audience. They ARE the target audience.
2. While they are mildly entertaining, there is one thing all of these ads have in common: they lack staying power. Think about all the Super bowl ads you remember. The really great ones. Were any of them the result of a contest?
For me, the most memorable ones have been The Budweiser frogs, Michael Jordan and Larry Bird’s Nothing but Net for McDonalds, Bud’s Wasssssup campaign, and more recently, Old Spice’s Smell Like a Man. All of which were created and produced by advertising agencies.
So after giving the consumer-created commercial trend some thought, you know what I say? The more, the merrier, guys. Because you may be able to speak to your fellow target audience and get your 15 minutes, but when it comes to selling something you know nothing about, that’s where the ad agency shines.